Sabeer Bhatia Advocates for Rethinking India’s GDP and Work Ethic
Sabeer Bhatia criticizes India’s GDP calculation for overstating economic output by focusing on monetary transactions rather than actual work. He proposes a shift to an hourly contribution system for measuring productivity. Bhatia also highlights the need for a stronger work ethic and better educational access, particularly among younger generations, to improve India’s competitiveness with China.
Sabeer Bhatia, the founder of Hotmail, critically evaluates India’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) calculation, asserting that it misrepresents the economic output. He argues that the current methodology, which emphasizes monetary transactions rather than tangible work performed, results in inflated figures. “Our GDP is all wrong. And I just—you just need two seconds to take a look at how they are computing GDP,” he stated, emphasizing the flawed basis of measuring economic productivity.
Bhatia highlighted how the Indian system accounts for money exchanged—illustrated by an example where 18% GST is counted multiple times without any actual work being done. This contrasts sharply with the United States’ approach, where GDP is determined by measurable work hours and associated value. “Everybody has an hourly rate. Everybody figures out how many hours of effort you put in and you report that to the government,” he explained.
To rectify these discrepancies, Bhatia proposes that India should implement a system based on hourly contributions, which assigns value directly to human effort. He suggests establishing standardized hourly rates across various professions and utilizing this framework to ensure productivity is measured by actual input rather than financial transactions. He remarked, “Hours of effort lead to progress, not transactions.”
Furthermore, Bhatia emphasizes the need for cultural shifts in work ethic and skills to directly compete with China. He mentions that India needs a stronger focus on developing practical skills among engineering graduates, who often opt for managerial paths rather than skill-based roles. He criticized this, stating, “99% of Indian who graduate as engineers join management and start giving gyaan to everybody.”
In terms of educational reform, Bhatia pointed out that India should facilitate broader access to education, akin to China’s subsidized education system. He remarked on the current scenario where quality education is mainly accessible to the affluent, hindering societal progress. “Education today is the prerogative of rich,” he lamented, proposing that technology could aid in fostering critical thinking without requiring vast infrastructure.
Bhatia concluded that meaningful change rests heavily on the younger generation to embrace challenges through innovative problem-solving founded on critical thinking. He optimistically noted that solving societal issues can enhance overall happiness and progress, reinforcing the idea that real advancements stem from collective problem solving and effort.
In summary, Sabeer Bhatia asserts that India’s approach to calculating GDP is flawed, as it prioritizes monetary exchanges over actual labor. He proposes a reformative model that emphasizes hourly work contributions to better reflect economic output. Furthermore, addressing the prevailing work ethic and increasing accessibility to education are vital for India’s competitive stance against China, particularly in fostering a culture of practical skills and problem-solving.
Original Source: m.economictimes.com
Post Comment